The following is all of the press we got over the years (minus interviews and mentions from compilation releases). I even included some of the bad reviews. I did this to illustrate how the same piece of music could affect people in different ways and also to show that I am not at all perturbed by a bad review, but rather amused by it. After reading some of these reviews again after so many years, I am very pleased by what we had accomplished and am at the same time appreciative of those who really dug what we did.
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 1991
First heard from last year on Galt Record's excellent "Hear No Evil" compilation, this Queens, NY based trio squeeze out sparkling psycho-pop on this, their debut LP. Simultaneously sunny and cynical, TEB deliver their goods wrapped in punk angst and tied with groovy pop ribbons. Hats off to chief songwriter and guitarist Julian Gallo who has penned a peck of witty, hooky tunes (Fave: "Life is Elsewhere") and bandmates Charles Caracciolo (drums) and Carol Rowan (bass) who, flailing with mad abandon, keeps Gallo's pop parked in the garage.
Jim Santo
Alternative Press
May 1992
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 1991
Intriguing 7-song effort from a Flushing, New York trio with the cutest female bass player I've seen since Naomi Young from Galaxie 500 was caught dancing in one of those "sophisticated" men's clubs in New Haven, CT (or was that the alcohol Neri gave me? Whatever.) Imagine The Vaselines crossed with Dinosaur Jr with a bigger eye turned toward the record labels.
Charis Missing
June 1992
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 1991
The first release from this trio is a 7-song EP. Pop music with a hard edged tinge. You can hear the punk and psychedelic backgrounds but you could also easily imagine hearing this on an AM radio.
Jersey Beat # 46
Summer 1992
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 1991
Third Eye Butterfly is a happy mix of the rough white noise guitars, double-time drum rolls and smooth, minor key vocals, perfectly harmonized. Their 7-song EP boils over with hyperactive tracks like the punk-tinged "Where Are We?" and "Lou Reed". Almost a ballad, "Play With The Rainmaker" is the only real departure from their usual uptempo songs, but lyrical and haunting. Each song is expertly catchy and like so many pieces of ecstatic shrapnel will stick in your mind happily ever after.
Sound Views # 20
November 1992
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 1991
More guitar pop, this time from a trio from NY called Third Eye Butterfly. Tough, jangly fuzzy guitars and loads of harmony vocals combine at 70s punk speed to make for a really cool sound. Tons of catchy hooks abound on these 7 songs that'll leave your mouth watering for more. After all, any band that has a song called "Lou Reed" has got to be cool.
What Wave? # 21
1992
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 1991
This group knows about hooks - those moments when melody, lyric, chorus framework, vocal presence, song title, and meaning are one. Their Squeeze-influenced lead and harmony vocal arrangements are fresh - I wonder if producer Dave Weiner had something to do with that and/or the mastery of pop-song structure displayed here (to his credit) - and just this side of goody-goody. Sometimes the way Charles or Julian (whoever sings lead) rounds off a lyric invokes Paul McCartney himself ("Teach The World", "Play With The Rainmaker"). They update the New Seekers on "Teach the World" (as in..."to sing in perfect harmony") and should probably be invited to sinf the next Coca-Cola jingle (I actually mean that as a compliment). And the major modulation to the mediant in "Where Are We?" is suitably disorienting and exciting. So what, you ask? I dare each one of you white noise bands to come up with one hook as strong as any of these on your next 4 track demo. This is pop for the best of reasons. And each hook sticks.
Jason Krasnow
Cake volume 11, Issue # 2
1992
What The Thunder Said
Psycho-Pop/Galt Records 191
Driving power pop aided by rich melodies, charged with a brutal blast of pure punk is what Third Eye Butterfly has to offer, and their 7 song EP is a real joy. In fact, they may just be the missing link between Teenage Fan Club and Nirvana! Punk aspirations most notably rear their head on "Everything I'm Living For", "Lou Reed", "Where Are We?" and "Life is Elsewhere", a dizzy rocker resembling a wild mixture of the Clash and the Who. On a poppier level, "Teach the World" and the jangly guitar of "Clouded Eyes". The lone slow number on "What The Thunder Said" is the haunting, harmony laden "Play With The Rainmaker" which radiates a strong baroque feel. This is a true masterpiece of music you don't want to pass up!
Pop Sunday Newsletter
1992
Live Review
Third Eye Butterfly offer a 60s influenced sound with a 90s relevance and they did it impressively at Nobody's December 5th. Drummer Charles Caracciolo is a superb double talent on drums and back up vocals. Carol Rowan's bass playing was both accurate and precise while Julian Gallo's guitar and vocals came with an image that remined us of Kurt from Nirvana.
The Angle Vol. 4, # 1
February 1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records, 1993
As expected, the new Third Eye Butterfly single is absolutely fabulous! Propelled by the clammor of thunderous drums that male you automatically think of Keith Moon, crossed with the chunky guitar riffing straight from the sonic landscape of Pete Townsend, "Skin" obviously pays homage to vintage Who. On the other hand, "Everything Falls Apart" is much more pop oriented, highlighted by compelling hooks and a bright and bouncy air. As an added bonus, this disc comes packaged in a real cute picture sleeve, but I'm not going to tell you what it looks like. Check it out for yourself!
Pop Sunday Newsletter
September 19th 1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
It's very appropriate that this record is on Psycho-Pop Records because each of the sides reflects a different half of the label's name. Side A is pop similar to slightly less noisy Husker Du (oddly enough they also share a title of a Husker song). It's an upbeat ditty with some well placed backing vocals. "Skin" is a psycho-dirgy rocker that sounds nothing like the A-side. It's like a different band. Third Eye Butterfly do both songs pretty well but it's really tough to imagine the two next to each other in one of the band's sets. They get an A for versatility but a B for consistency. This could confuse people
The Splatter Effect # 5
1993
'Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
Third Eye Butterfly's new 7-inch sounds like a split-release between two drastically different bands! "Everything Falls Apart" is a hummable Cure-esque pop song with a real late 60s vibe, not unlike their track on the Sound Views comp. The B-side, "Skin" i a hard, fuzzed out pop stomper a la Nirvana. I liked both tracks although a little continuity would be nice.
Sound Views # 26
December 1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
The A-side is good guitar based pop chock full of harmonies---I don't know id this is Third Eye Butterfly's sound or not but it's done really well. The B-side, "Skin" is an okay mid-tempo number with no harmonies tht makes the A-side even better. On red vynyl with a full color sleeve.
Under The Volcano # 15
1993
"Everything Falls Apart" / "Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
The A-side isn't the Husker Du song (unfortunately). Harder college-pop stuff ruined by "we are the world" type lyrics on side two and music that wants the best of both worlds: "rocking out" (ugh), indie sound, bouncy melodies and so on but just ends up sounding as annonymous as the other stuff I usually get in my P.O. Box.
Chairs Missing
October 1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
"Everything Falls Apart is a stab at fuzzed out power-pop. The melody is great but the lyrics are a bit mundane. The weakest link here, however, is the vocals which unfortunately can't cut through the clutter and become distinctive. "Skin" is a driving rocker powered by full force guitars and upbeat skin pounding; hooky and infectous.
The Village Noize #15
1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7" / "What The Thunder Said" EP (1991)
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
"Everything Falls Apart is a crashing piece of power-pop masquerading as garage-grunge. The flip is garage-grunge without apology. The EP is more of the same with air-tight melodies floating to the top of their musical swamp. "Everything I'm Living For" is brilliant pop---like the Plimsouls mudwrestling with Nirvana. "Teach The World" could be a commercial jingle (wasn't it?). All the rest is equally good stuff rife with folk-rock moves and uncompromising garage/punk inflections. The metamorphosed Third Eye Butterfly has clearly left grunge's cacoon behind, having taken flight with colorful pop wings. Let your ears be the net.
Yellow Pills
1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
No doubt about it, "Everything..." is an absolute stone classic that sounds like it could be a missing track from "Singles Going Steady". It's got everything---chiming guitars, a pounding beat, pissed off, unlucky in love lyrics and a chorus that just won't quit. The flip is decent but the A-side makes this one of my top 45s of the year.
Foster Child
1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
Buzzcocks influenced bubblegum punk band. "Everything Falls Apart" just starts soaring right away with teenage heartbreak lyrics and sugar sweet melodies. I'm a sucker for this stuff!
Maximum Rock-N-Roll
1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
Third Eye Butterfly's new 7" sound like two different bands! The A-Side, is power-pop. The B-side, "Skin", with it's deep rumble to scare off rain clouds is more in line of how inspired this band could get.
Buzzzz
1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
Local band's debut 7" is not the Husker Du song though it is similar classic punky pop with a melody a sharp and as memorable as that the Husker's first brush with lasting greatness eleven years ago. The looping bassline and up-tempo cheerful up/down chords suggest folks who are so damn happy to be playing it seeps through the drum fills and especially Julian Gallo and Charlie Caracciolo's soaring twin vocals in the chorus, and it's a really good song from the first play.
Jack Rabid
The Big Takeover
1993
"Everything Falls Apart"/"Skin" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1993
TEB gets heavy with "Skin", a dark, driving number with ballsy vox from drummer Charles Caracciolo, then lightens up with "Everything...", in a classic piece of post-punk pop in the Who/Kinks/Jam/Buzzcocks tradition. This single is a must have, but see 'em live.
Andy Glass
The Musicians Exchange
1993
"Life Is Elsewhere"/"Play With The Rainmaker" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1994
"Life is Elsewhere" is an ambitious pop gem that really works. From the simple three chord structure to the bright vocals, the track is happy-sounding and instantly hummable despite the lyrical content. "Play With The Rainmaker" is more dour and serious, though still with a pop sense at it's core. This dark, thick ballad represents some very fine songwriting.
The Village Noise # 17
1994
"Life Is Elsewhere"/"Play With The Rainmaker" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1994
Third Eye Butterfly, a NY-based trio has just released their second 7" single, "Life is Elsewhere" b/w "Play With The Rainmaker". It's got hooks. Catchy hooks. I mean really catchy. You'll definitely be singing the chorus after the first listen. "Liiiiiife is elsewhere". Belive me. It almost crosses the line into sappy pop zone but thankfully it remains on the right side of the border. In other words they've got a good balance of punk pop, driving fuzzy guitars, a pounding beat and incredible vocal harmonies. The strong songwriting, energetic guitars, plesantly incessant drumming and cynical lyrics make for a well crafted record. The B-side is slower-paced and almost a ballad. "Don't ever expect me to smile again" sings Gallo. Pick this one up. You'll smile (even if you don't want to).
What Now? # 1
December 1994
"Life Is Elsewhere"/"Play With The Rainmaker" 7"
Psycho-Pop Records 1994
Flushing Queens' Third Eye Butterfly's second single builds on the promise of their first, "Everything Falls Apart" three times over. "Life is Elswhere" may be what every teen or suburban-dweller feels but New York City isn't that boring. So this song is about a once humming relationship gone stale as last night's Blimpie submarine sandwich and it's set to a biting Ned's Atomic Dustbin-style groove, well propelled by much-tightened rhythm section Charles and Carol Caracciolo. Gallo's slashing at his over effects driven guitar is a great contrast to his likable, put-upon and bemused voice. Like all great 7"ers, it makes one reach for the "repeat" button on the turntable so you can sing along. Moreover, the flip, "Play With The Rainmaker" is a refreshing about-turn, a classic 60s waltz with an enlivening acoustic top to bottom tag line. More bands need a 6/8 time song, it's such good variety. Here's a NY band in need of a full-length release if this is the repertoire they have up their sleeves.
Jack Rabid
The Big Takeover # 36
1994